Get More Leads, Sales, and Revenue With Digital Marketing That Delivers Results

Home / Blog / Marketing

Marketing

eBay vs Amazon vs Etsy: Which Should a New Seller Start With?

Three marketplaces, three very different ways to start. Here is how the fees, the setup and the type of buyer compare, so you can pick one on purpose.

By MAQ Digital Media team12 November 20268 min read
Two people packing online orders at a table with a laptop, preparing parcels to sell on eBay, Amazon or Etsy

Key takeaways

  • There is no best marketplace. The right one depends on what you sell, your starting budget and how much setup work you want on day one.
  • eBay is usually the gentlest place to learn, Etsy suits handmade and vintage items, and Amazon asks the most of a new seller in rules, approvals and ad spend.
  • On a $40 item with free shipping, standard fees came to about $5.84 on eBay, $4.25 on Etsy and $6.99 on Amazon Individual, before shipping, stock cost and ads.
  • Amazon Professional ($39.99 a month) only beats Individual ($0.99 an item) once you sell roughly 40 items a month.
  • Start on one marketplace, cost every product properly, and add a second only when the first runs smoothly.

The short answer

There is no single best marketplace. The better question is which one fits what you sell, how much you can spend on stock, and how much work you want to take on in the first month.

As a rule of thumb, eBay suits used, vintage, collectible and one-off items and is the gentlest place to learn. Etsy suits handmade, vintage and craft items where the look and the story matter. Amazon suits branded or repeatable products where you can compete on price, reviews and delivery, and it asks the most of you in rules, approvals and advertising. That is our reading of how the three work, not a promise of results. Your product and your costs decide the outcome.

What each marketplace is like for a new seller

eBay

eBay is built around individual listings. You can sell one-off items, auction-style or fixed price, and a new seller can get a first listing live quickly. Buyers often arrive looking for a specific item, which suits secondhand goods, parts, collectibles and surplus stock. The trade-off is that you compete with many sellers on price for common items, and your feedback record matters.

Etsy

Etsy is built around handmade, vintage and craft supplies. Shoppers come to find something with character, so photos, titles, tags and shop presentation do most of the selling. It is a good fit if you make the product yourself. It is a poor fit if you plan to resell generic goods, because Etsy’s seller policies set out what can be listed. Read them before you source anything.

Amazon

Amazon has the biggest shopper habit of the three, and buyers there are usually ready to buy. For many products you list against an existing product page, so you compete with other sellers on price, delivery and seller performance. Some categories and brands need approval, and most sellers end up paying for advertising to be seen. If you are weighing Amazon seriously, our guide to what a good ACoS looks like on Amazon PPC shows what that ad cost can mean for your margin.

What each one costs: current US seller fees

We read each marketplace’s own fee pages on 12 November 2026. These are the standard US figures for a new seller. Category rates differ, so check your category before you commit.

  • eBay: the first 250 listings a month are free for sellers without a store, then $0.35 each. The final value fee is 13.6% of the total sale amount (item price, buyer-paid shipping and sales tax) up to $7,500 for most categories, plus a per-order fee of $0.30 on orders up to $10 and $0.40 above that.
  • Amazon: the Individual plan charges $0.99 per item sold. The Professional plan is $39.99 a month. Both pay a referral fee on top, which is a percentage of the price. Most common rates are 15%, with many categories at 8% to 12%, and most categories have a $0.30 minimum. Fulfilment by Amazon costs extra.
  • Etsy: a $0.20 listing fee per listing, a 6.5% transaction fee, and payment processing of 3% plus $0.25 per order in the US. Offsite Ads costs 15% of the order (12% once your shop passes $10,000 in a year) but only on orders that come from those ads, capped at $100 an order. We found no monthly subscription fee on Etsy’s fee pages.

A worked example

Take a $40 item, free shipping, no sales tax and a standard category. Using the fees above:

  • eBay: $5.44 final value fee plus $0.40 order fee, about $5.84 (14.6%).
  • Amazon Individual: $6.00 referral fee at 15% plus $0.99, about $6.99 (17.5%). On Professional it is $6.00 plus the monthly fee.
  • Etsy: $0.20 listing, $2.60 transaction, $1.45 processing, about $4.25 (10.6%). If the sale came from an Offsite Ad, add $6.00, about $10.25 (25.6%).

This is arithmetic from the published rates, not a forecast. It leaves out the product cost, shipping labels, returns, advertising, taxes and currency fees. Fees are not profit, and the cheapest fee page does not automatically mean the best marketplace for your product.

One more number worth knowing: $39.99 a month divided by $0.99 an item is about 40. If you expect to sell fewer than roughly 40 items a month on Amazon, the Individual plan costs less. Above that, Professional does.

How to pick based on your situation

  • You have used, vintage or collectible items, or surplus stock: start with eBay. Listings are quick, and you learn how shipping, returns and buyer messages work with little setup.
  • You make the product yourself: start with Etsy. Your photos, title and tags carry the sale, and the fee structure is simple to cost.
  • You have a branded or private label product: Amazon is where the shopper demand is, but plan for category approval, delivery standards and an advertising budget before you order stock.
  • You plan to buy from suppliers and ship direct: read the dropshipping rules on each marketplace first. They are not the same, and a breach can cost you the account.
  • You are not sure: pick the one that matches your product best, not the one with the lowest fees.

Mistakes new sellers make

  • Listing everywhere at once. Stock goes out of sync, an item sells twice and you cancel an order. That hurts your account.
  • Choosing on fees alone. A lower fee does not help if your buyer is on a different marketplace.
  • Skipping the rules for your category. Restricted items, brand approvals and sourcing rules are where new accounts get into trouble.
  • Not costing each product. Work out landed cost, fees, shipping and likely returns per unit before you buy stock.
  • Copying competitors’ listings. Use your own photos and wording. Copied listings can break marketplace rules and rarely convert as well.

A sensible starting plan

  1. Pick five to ten products and cost each one: purchase or production cost, marketplace fees, shipping, packaging and an allowance for returns.
  2. Open one marketplace account and list those products properly, with your own photos and clear titles.
  3. Track sales, messages, returns and the real margin for 30 to 60 days.
  4. Add a second marketplace only when the first runs without fire-fighting.

If you would rather have help with setup, we work with sellers on all three. See our eBay virtual assistant services, our Amazon account management services and our Etsy shop management services, or meet the specialist who handles them. If you want a store of your own as well, our guide to what a Shopify store costs is a useful next read.

Sources

Fee facts were read from the marketplaces’ own pages on 12 November 2026. Fees change, so confirm on the page before you price anything.

Frequently asked questions

Which is easiest for a complete beginner: eBay, Amazon or Etsy?

For most beginners eBay is the easiest to start with, because you can list single items quickly and there are few barriers for common categories. Etsy is just as easy if you make your own products. Amazon usually takes more preparation because of category approvals, delivery standards and advertising.

Can I sell on eBay, Amazon and Etsy at the same time?

Many sellers do. Each marketplace has its own terms, so read them for your product type. The practical risk is stock: if one item sells on two marketplaces at once, you have to cancel an order. Keep stock counts in sync before you list in more than one place.

Which marketplace has the lowest fees?

On our $40 example, Etsy was lowest at about $4.25 and Amazon Individual highest at about $6.99, but only before advertising. An Offsite Ad sale on Etsy or paid ads on Amazon change the picture. Compare the total cost to make a sale, not just the fee page.

Do I need a registered business to start selling?

The rules depend on the marketplace and on where you live. Each one asks for identity and payout details, and tax duties depend on your country. Check the seller registration page of the marketplace you choose and ask an accountant about your own situation.

Is Amazon Individual or Professional better?

Individual charges $0.99 per item sold. Professional is $39.99 a month. Divide the monthly fee by the per-item fee and the break-even is about 40 items a month. Below that, Individual costs less. Check which features each plan includes before you decide.

Is Etsy only for handmade products?

Etsy is built around handmade items, vintage items and craft supplies. It is not a general resale marketplace, and its seller policies set out what you can list. If you plan to source finished goods from suppliers, read those policies first.

Is dropshipping allowed on eBay, Amazon and Etsy?

Each marketplace has its own rules and they are not the same. Some forms of dropshipping are allowed with conditions and others are not. Read the current policy on each marketplace before you list, because a breach can lead to restrictions on your account.

Do I have to pay for advertising to sell?

No marketplace makes ads mandatory for every seller, but they matter more on some than others. Amazon sellers often rely on paid ads to get seen. Etsy enrols shops in Offsite Ads automatically, and shops under $10,000 a year in sales can opt out. Cost your product with and without ad spend.

Where we can help

Not sure which marketplace fits your product? Our team can help you compare and set up the right one.

Choosing where to sell first?

Tell us what you sell and your budget. We will give you a clear view of which marketplace to start with and what to set up first.

Request a free auditWhatsApp us

Written by the MAQ Digital Media team. Platform features, policies and interfaces change often, so check each platform’s current help documentation before acting on any step. Last reviewed 12 November 2026.